Pete Alonso has been one of the most consistent power hitters in baseball since making his MLB debut with the New York Mets. Averaging 42 home runs and 110 RBIs over five full seasons, Alonso has built a reputation as a middle-of-the-order force who can change the game with one swing. Yet, as the offseason progresses, the 30-year-old first baseman remains unsigned, with teams hesitant to commit to him long-term.
Alonso’s free-agent market has been surprisingly quiet, despite his impressive track record. ESPN’s Jeff Passan points to concerns about Alonso’s player profile as the main reason teams are reluctant to offer a blockbuster deal. “On one hand, Alonso’s consistent production is unimpeachable,” Passan said. “On the other, his profile frightens teams: a 30-year-old, right-handed-hitting and -throwing first baseman.”
Historically, right-handed-hitting first basemen have faced challenges securing lucrative long-term contracts as they enter their 30s. Teams worry about declining production due to age and the limited defensive value of the position. While Alonso’s durability and power are undeniable, front offices appear cautious about how those traits will hold up over a lengthy deal.
Another factor complicating Alonso’s market is the Mets’ recent spending spree. New York made headlines by signing superstar Juan Soto to a historic 15-year, $765 million deal earlier this offseason. While Soto’s presence dramatically upgrades the Mets’ lineup, it also raises questions about whether the team is willing to invest heavily in Alonso.
The Mets still have a glaring hole at first base, and bringing back Alonso would make sense. However, with other big spenders like the Yankees rumored to be monitoring his situation, the Mets may face stiff competition if they hope to re-sign their homegrown slugger.
For Alonso, the hesitation surrounding his profile likely means he will land a strong contract but not the long-term mega-deal he might have envisioned. A shorter deal with high annual value could be the compromise teams find appealing, allowing them to capitalize on his power in the near term without the risk of a lengthy commitment.
Despite the challenges, Alonso’s consistent offensive production ensures he will be a valuable asset wherever he lands. As the offseason progresses, his market is expected to heat up, and his next contract will serve as a litmus test for how teams value aging sluggers in today’s analytical era.
