In a fiery Senate confirmation hearing, President-elect Donald Trump’s nominee for defense secretary, Pete Hegseth, found himself battling allegations of misconduct, scrutiny over his qualifications, and intense questioning about his controversial views on women in combat. The former Army National Guard officer and ex-Fox News host vowed to instill a “warrior culture” at the Pentagon while deflecting concerns about his past.
Hegseth, 44, who has faced allegations of sexual assault, excessive drinking, and marital infidelity, dismissed the claims as part of a “smear campaign” and emphasized his combat experience in Iraq and Afghanistan. “It’s time to give someone with dust on his boots the helm,” he declared, presenting himself as a “change agent” ready to shake up the Pentagon.
Allegations and a Divided Senate
The hearing, which stretched over four hours, was marked by partisan divisions. Republican senators defended Hegseth as a breath of fresh air for the military, while Democrats grilled him on allegations of misconduct and his controversial views. Sen. Jack Reed (D-R.I.), the top Democrat on the Armed Services Committee, described the allegations as “extremely alarming” and stated bluntly: “I do not believe that you are qualified to meet the overwhelming demands of this job.”
Hegseth denied the allegations of sexual assault, claiming the encounter was consensual and that the matter was resolved with a confidential settlement. He acknowledged his imperfections, saying, “I am not a perfect person,” but insisted he was ready to lead.
Controversial Views on Diversity and Women in Combat
Hegseth’s opposition to modern diversity initiatives and his past comments about women in combat took center stage during the hearing. Several female Democratic senators confronted him, including Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-Ill.), a combat veteran who lost both legs in Iraq. Duckworth challenged his competence to lead, stating, “The troops cannot be led by someone who is not competent.”
Hegseth softened his stance on women in combat, a position he had previously criticized. “I will serve every man and woman in uniform,” he assured. However, his remarks on dismantling diversity programs drew sharp criticism, with Sen. Kristen Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) demanding he reevaluate his perspective on inclusion.
A Controversial Pick
Hegseth, whose credentials are unconventional for a defense secretary, has no senior military or national security leadership experience. The Pentagon’s vast responsibilities—managing over 2.1 million service members and overseeing an $850 billion budget—are a far cry from Hegseth’s background as a television commentator and National Guard officer.
His nomination has sparked fierce debates. Supporters likened him to Trump, applauding his outsider status and promise to disrupt the status quo. Critics, however, pointed to his divisive rhetoric and lack of administrative expertise as potential liabilities.
Trump’s Gamble and GOP Support
Republicans, holding a slim Senate majority, are rallying behind Hegseth as a symbol of Trump’s governing philosophy. Outside groups, including conservative think tanks, have launched campaigns to bolster his bid. Sen. Markwayne Mullin (R-Okla.) defended Hegseth, saying, “We’ve all made mistakes,” while Sen. Joni Ernst (R-Iowa) highlighted the nominee’s pledge to serve all service members with honor.
Yet, Hegseth’s confirmation remains uncertain. Many senators are awaiting access to his FBI background check, which Democratic leaders claim is insufficient. Calls for a more thorough review have so far been rebuffed by the Trump transition team.
A Pentagon in Crisis
If confirmed, Hegseth would inherit a military grappling with recruitment struggles, funding challenges, and multiple global crises. The role demands strategic decision-making, as the defense secretary oversees U.S. deployments, NATO partnerships, and international security negotiations.
Hegseth’s nomination reflects Trump’s broader approach to governance, prioritizing loyalty and disruptive leadership. Whether this gamble pays off or backfires will be determined in the coming days as the Senate prepares for a final vote.